How Family Dynamics Shape Your Medical Relationships: Finding Your Voice

Have you ever noticed how you slip into familiar patterns when visiting family? Or felt dismissed by a doctor despite knowing something was wrong with your body? These experiences might be more connected than you realize.

In our latest podcast episode, I spoke with Dr. Jackie Williams-Reade, a licensed marriage and family therapist with a PhD in medical family therapy. Our conversation explored how childhood family roles can impact everything from your health to how you navigate difficult conversations decades later.

The Hidden Patterns in Family Systems

"Our training is very clear that [patients] are holding the symptoms of a much larger problem that's going on in their family life or social context," Jackie explained early in our conversation.

Unlike individual therapy that might focus primarily on what's happening inside you, family therapists look for patterns in how people interact. These patterns often begin in childhood but continue shaping our relationships—including with medical providers—throughout our lives.

The Family Roles We Play (Whether We Know It or Not)

Families naturally seek balance, or what therapists call "homeostasis." To maintain this balance, family members take on different roles:

  • The Hero – The achiever who brings positive attention to the family

  • The Clown – The one who defuses tension with humor

  • The Scapegoat – The person who gets blamed for family problems

When Your Voice Wasn't Welcome: The Lasting Impact

The scapegoat role can be particularly damaging. Children who were blamed for family problems often grow up doubting their perceptions and feelings.

"Almost a hundred percent of the time, [women with chronic illness] were also really a scapegoat in their family as a child," Jackie observed. "They were seeing things and wanting to be honest... and they get in trouble for it."

This pattern can follow you into adulthood, affecting how you:

  • Advocate for yourself with doctors

  • Set boundaries in relationships

  • Trust your own experiences and feelings

Check In With Yourself

The next time you feel reluctant to speak up about physical symptoms or emotional needs, ask yourself, "Am I worried about being 'too much' or 'causing problems'?" This awareness is often the first step toward change.

Agency & Communion: The Balancing Act We All Need to Master

One of the most powerful concepts Jackie discussed was the balance between agency (voicing your needs) and communion (maintaining relationships):

This balance is crucial in medical settings. 

You need agency to ask questions and advocate for yourself, but also communion to maintain a productive relationship with your healthcare team.

In Practice

Before your next medical appointment, write down your top three concerns. Practice saying them clearly and directly: "I've noticed [symptom] and I'm concerned because [reason]. What can we do to address this?"

Setting Boundaries Without Cutting People Off

Many people assume boundaries mean distance or cutting people off entirely. Jackie offered a more nuanced approach:

Instead of "Don't ever talk to me about that again," try: "When you talk about that, it really bothers me. Can we leave that out of our conversations going forward?"

This approach maintains connection while protecting yourself—but there is important nuance here. Sometimes, the difficult conversations are exactly what is needed to happen for healing. 

For instance, setting a boundary about how your mother criticizes your parenting choices ("I need you to stop commenting on how I discipline my children") is different from avoiding important topics entirely ("Let's never discuss our conflicting political views").

The Key Distinction

Is this boundary protecting you from harm, or is it preventing necessary growth? A healthy boundary might sound like: "I can discuss our past conflict, but I need you to listen without interrupting when I share my experience." 

This creates safety while still allowing for meaningful connection. In contrast, "Let's just pretend that never happened" might feel safer in the moment but prevents the authentic connection that true healing requires.

The goal is to create enough safety that genuine conversations become possible, even when they're difficult.

The Help Paradox: Why Accepting Support Is So Hard (And So Important)

If you were scapegoated as a child, asking for help might feel dangerous. Your needs may have been treated as burdensome, creating a lifelong reluctance to seek support.

Jackie offered a brilliant starting point: "Sometimes you don't even have to ask for help. You just have to not say no when people offer you help."

Small Step Challenge

The next time someone offers assistance—even something small—practice saying "Yes, thank you" instead of your automatic "No, I'm fine."

Redefining Healing: It's Progress, Not Perfection

Perhaps the most liberating insight from our conversation was about healing itself. 

As Dr. Jackie Williams-Reade put it:

Healing isn't about never reacting poorly again. It's about noticing when you do, understanding why, and trying a different approach next time. It’s about making these decisions from a place of how you want your life to look, NOT from a place of fear.

Your Turn: From Insight to Action

Understanding these patterns is just the beginning. 

Here are three ways to apply these insights this week:

  1. Notice your family role. In what situations do you slip into being the peacemaker, the problem-solver, or perhaps the scapegoat?

  2. Practice balanced boundaries. Choose one relationship where you'll practice setting a boundary while maintaining connection.

  3. Accept one offer of help. When someone offers assistance this week, simply say "yes" and notice how it feels.

What family patterns have you noticed affecting your health or relationships? Share your reflections in the comments below, or join our community discussion in our private Facebook group.

Connect with Dr. Jackie Williams-Reade at www.kardiacounselingcenter.com.

Buy Jackie’s Textbook for Therapists: Self of the Therapist in Medical Settings: A Sociocultural and Systemic Perspective

Disclaimer: Everything we discuss here is just meant to be general education and information. It's not intended as personal mental health or medical advice. If you have any questions related to your unique circumstances, please contact a licensed therapist or medical professional in your state of residence.

Listen to Dr. Jackie’s interview with me, Destiny, on Ep 90: The Medical System Wants To Scapegoat You - Don't Let Them w/ Jackie Williams-Reade, PhD, LMFT, LCPC

Listen on Apple

Listen on Spotify

 
Podcast cover art for "The Chronic Illness Therapist Podcast" with Destiny Davis, LPC CRC

Listen to Dr. Jackie’s interview with me, Destiny, on Ep 90: The Medical System Wants To Scapegoat You - Don't Let Them w/ Jackie Williams-Reade, PhD, LMFT, LCPC

Listen on Apple

Listen on Spotify


Jackie Williams-Reade, Licensed Marriage and family therapist, smiling wearing a white buttoned shirt in front of a green hedge

Dr. Jackie Williams-Reade is a licensed marriage and family therapist in California and Montana with a PhD in medical family therapy. She specializes in helping patients with cancer and those living with grief and loss, utilizing medical family therapy, Bowen family systems, and mind-body awareness approaches in her private practice.

Connect with Dr. Jackie:

Website


Destiny Davis, LPC CRC, smiling in a pink sweater standing outdoors with crossed arms

Meet Destiny - The host of The Chronic Illness Therapist Podcast and a licensed mental health therapist in the states of Georgia and Florida. Destiny offers traditional 50-minute therapy sessions as well as therapy intensives and monthly online workshops for the chronic illness community.

Previous
Previous

Eliminating Medical Debt: How DollarFor Is Helping Patients Access Hospital Charity Care

Next
Next

Redefine Success